Nothing enrages me more than a password character limit. Thank you for making sure my password is LESS secure with your idiotic requirements based on security recommendations that are at least a decade old.
How about… an undisclosed character limit? We’ll just keep telling you your password is invalid until you figure out the max length.
Fun fact, this is a feature of Lemmy:
- Lemmy has an undisclosed password limit of 60 characters.
- Lemmy’s signup form will silently truncate passwords longer than 60 characters to 60 characters.
- Lemmy’s login form will crash when passwords longer than 60 characters are submitted.
Someone please submit a PR
Just move to kbin.
Let the users enter as many characters as they want and silently crop the password to a few characters.
I’ve run into this where the sign-up form silently truncated the password but the login form didn’t. Took me several password resets to guess the thing was being trimmed to 16 characters.
I would give up before I figured that out and find some other service to use.
banks using EXACTLY 8 character passwords 💀 (srsly)
Try this simple and fun game to practice your password creation skills :^) https://neal.fun/password-game/
Convince me this isn’t just training someone’s pet algorithm the same way we’ve all been trained to accept training the CAPTCHAs.
WAKE UP COMPILERS (It is a fun game though)
My bank requires your password to contain NO vowels. I always forget when I update the password (forced to every 3 months) and the error never mentions it.
I’m struggling to think why this would be a thing. The only guess I have is someone was told to enforce “no dictionary words in a password” and saw that as an ‘easier’ way to implement?
One one hand it reduces the total # of characters needed to brute force which is bad. On the other hand, like you said, it makes it so dictionary attacks are weaker - which is good
Although I think you could just get a regular dictionary, remove the vowels, and it would probably work just fine
So ultimately? I think stupid decision
Th3y w4nt p4ssw0rds l1k3 th1s, 1ts m0r3 l33t
I get so irrationally mad about passwords now, and then it’s like every 3 months, no matter what password phrase I come up with, with whatever non-sensual special characters and spaces added in, it’s compromised in some hack, so no matter how good your password is, they’ll just get it from the source anyways.
I just use the KeePassXC password generator. :)
Way too often I’ve had websites complain that the input password is too complex, and I have to dial down the settings.
Creating a password is as easy as clicking generate in my password manager - y’all should use one too
This is the only way. Except some services don’t even accept those randomly generated ones. Only a slight inconvenience to add whatever special character they want or to trim the length.
Inconvenience? More like incompetence… they should let me use æøéüôñ🍕&/ in my passphrase
And not in the user’s last X passwords! And doesn’t contain their name, address etc! And changes every X days!
Literally writing code to do this rn, even tho I pushed back with modern theories… IT security “experts” set policy using just enough knowledge to be dangerous
One of the banned words hardcoded previously was “monkey”, needless to say I am proud to carry on this tradition
Twitter!
Reminds me of “The Password Game” 😂
I’ve seen some sites grade passwords from weak to strong instead of using explicit rules, but I’m not sure exactly how they’re graded. Probably some sort of entropy approximation.
Probably some sort of entropy approximation.
That’s exactly what it is, and that is the correct way to do it.
All those ridiculous letter/case/symbol/number rules come from guidelines written by Bill Burr for NIST 20 years ago. He has since stated that he regrets them, and NIST has abandoned them. Because they’re actually counterproductive to security.
NIST has abandoned them
Would that my IT department had gotten the memo. They think NIST is god-tier, even when our own CS department is like… yeah, no. And personally, having worked with NIST researchers in fields that aren’t IT policy, I wonder how good their IT policy docs really are. The whole organization is bureaucracy getting in the way of good science and common sense.
Yup. Hard to remember, easy to guess.
Isn’t Bill Burr a comedian, though?Different Burr.
Sorry, that password is already in use.
Who’s using it? I’ll just use that account.
Just reset your username using your password
