• 1 Post
  • 401 Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: June 14th, 2023

help-circle

  • My issue is that on the (?second) day of the war, a group of Western reporters were presented with “evidence” of the planning that had gone into the attack, and I found the “evidence” to be laughably bad - the evidence itself, the supposed circumstances it was found under, the condition of the evidence - all were bad. And if you present such incredibly poor “evidence” at one point, I’m going to automatically be much more suspicious of any other “evidence” you present later.




  • Here, let me fix that for you:

    The Israeli Army, after ten weeks in which they have repeatedly and intentionally hit non-military, civilian, neutral observer, refugee and journalist targets; in which they have deliberately and indiscriminately murdered thousands of noncombatants during acts of ethnic cleansing and genocide, during which they’ve also deliberately murdered their own unarmed and half-naked citizens; bombing hospitals, refugee camps, and the supposed “safe evacuation corridors” they explicitly told the civilian population to use; and after repeatedly lying about and defending their attacks; an onslaught which has been met with almost universal condemnation from the community of nations; has finally admitted, after ten weeks of indiscriminate slaughter, that maybe, just maybe two of their attacks might’ve been misjudged - Oops.











  • Are you confusing this with Trumps fraud trial, where his lawyers fucked up and did not request a jury trial, so he had a bench trial

    Actually, there was never any option for a bench trial there. The media saw the submission form, which had an unchecked box for “jury trial”, but it’s a standard form that covers multiple types of trials. Like when you go to DMV and get your driver’s license renewed, there are all sorts of options for commercial and motorcycle licenses as well but you never check those sections because they’re not applicable to you.





  • I don’t doubt there are Hamas tunnels, either. That said, Israel has presented no proof that the tunnels at the hospital actually were Hamas tunnels. They actively prevented journalists from entering the tunnels and, afaik, there was only one video from ‘inside’ the tunnel that contained no proof that it was actually the hospital tunnel.

    I find it hard to give Israel the benefit of the doubt on their claims after they claimed that an almost pristine document had been found on the body of a Hamas fighter deep in the initial attack.



  • Counterpoints:

    We know that tunnels have been found in Gazan hospital complexes. There has been no credible evidence that these were Hamas tunnels. Most hospitals I’ve worked at have had tunnels or underground hallways - hell, my high school had tunnels. The existence of “a tunnel entrance” that the Israelis refuse to let independent journalists into proves nothing.

    We know by video evidence that injured hostages were taken to hospitals. Seems like install wins either way: either Hamas brings in prisoners for treatment and then suddenly the entire hospital is a Hamas compound and everyone there is affiliated with Hamas; or they don’t bring in prisoners for treatment and they’re barbarians who don’t understand the way that ‘civilized’ people conduct war. [Hey, how come Israel gets to kidnap Palestinians off the street and call them prisoners, but when Hamas does it, suddenly they’re hostages?]

    I have seen no hostage testimony that doctors kept hostages jailed. I have read that hostages were unable to leave after getting treatment, but that doesn’t mean it was the doctors preventing them leaving.

    Why are my comments important? Because Israel knows it’s losing public support for it’s war. Trying to demonize both the UN and the WHO [both of whom are targets of US conservatives] attempts to keep US conservatives strongly aligned with Israeli government interests.