All things are possible through Christ!

  • 0 Posts
  • 93 Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: June 11th, 2023

help-circle





  • Personally, it’s the implausibility of 2 that makes all of this seem like no big deal to me. In fact, I think federating openly with Threads might signal to Threads users that they can use alternatives and not lose access to whomever they follow on Threads, thus growing the user-base of other federated instances.

    I think people who are going to use Threads for Meta-specific features are likely going to use Threads anyway, and if any of those features are genuinely good (i.e. not simply Instagram and Facebook tie-ins) they will be replicated by the various open Fediverse projects which already differ from one another in terms of features.

    The moderation issue is entirely different and there are some instances that have an understanding with their users about protecting them from seeing any objectionable content or behavior as defined by whatever culture they have. Defederating from such a large group of people makes sense, perhaps even preemptively, no different from when they defederate existing large instances now.













  • tl;dw

    • Cory Doctorow coins the term “enshittification” to describe how platforms start out benefiting users but eventually abuse users and business customers to extract all value.

    • Facebook started by prioritizing user privacy over ads but now prioritizes profits over all else.

    • Network effects are a double-edged sword - they lock users in but also make platforms vulnerable if users leave en masse.

    • Low switching costs due to universality and interoperability allow competitors to reverse engineer platforms and plug in competing services.

    • Mandatory interoperability and limiting data control can curb platform power by distributing control to users and smaller companies.

    • Recent antitrust actions aim to roll back decades of lax merger policy that let platforms consolidate power.

    • Breakups will take a long time so interoperability is a faster way to restore competition.

    • Laws should limit abusive behavior rather than rely on platforms to self-regulate.

    • Federated open services fail gracefully and encourage migration to better platforms.

    • Political will is growing but change will be gradual - focus should be on harm reduction in the near term.